H-1B Deference: Michigan Urges Withdrawal as Comments Close 13 November

One of America's best-known universities has stepped into the fight over the future of H-1B extensions — and the clock is almost out. The University of Michigan has filed formal comments urging the Department of Homeland Security to withdraw its proposal to end deference to past approvals, warning that the change would inject fresh uncertainty into the lives of extension seekers. The public comment period closes tomorrow, 13 November. If you hold an H-1B, L-1, O-1 or another petition-based visa, this is the rule that decides whether your next extension is treated as a routine renewal or a brand-new case.

The University of Michigan campus in Ann Arbor

Photo: Jha4ceb, CC BY-SA 4.0 — via Wikimedia Commons

What Michigan actually said

Michigan's comments, filed on 12 November, oppose the Department of Homeland Security's plan to remove the requirement that US Citizenship and Immigration Services generally defer to its own prior approvals when the facts of a case have not changed. The university's central argument is about certainty: workers and employers who have already been through the full approval process once should not have to prove the same case from scratch every time they extend.

The objection matters because of who is making it. Universities are among the largest employers of H-1B workers in the United States, and Michigan is one of the most prominent. Its intervention lands on the eve of the deadline, when the department is taking its final tally of public views before deciding whether to push ahead with a final rule.

What the proposal would change

The proposal, published on 14 October as 91 FR 65119 under docket USCIS-2026-0529, would delete the deference provision at 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5). That provision tells adjudicators to generally defer to a prior approval when a new petition involves the same parties and the same facts. Remove it, and every extension becomes a fresh adjudication — with a fresh chance of a request for evidence, or a denial.

The change would reach far beyond H-1B workers. It covers extensions filed on Form I-129, which includes H-1B, L-1, O-1, TN, E and P petitions. Our deep-dive from yesterday explains the mechanics of the proposal in full, including how deference works today and why its removal would slow the system down.

ItemDetail
Proposal91 FR 65119, published 14 October 2026
DocketUSCIS-2026-0529
Rule to be deleted8 CFR 214.1(c)(5) — deference to prior approvals
Petitions affectedI-129 extensions: H-1B, L-1, O-1, TN, E, P
Comments close13 November 2026, via Regulations.gov
Status todayProposal only — deference still applies

The numbers behind the rule

The department's own estimates show how wide the impact would be. About 208,429 petitions a year were eligible for deference in fiscal years 2022 to 2025 — roughly 30% of all I-129 petitions filed in that period. In other words, nearly one in three petition-based cases currently benefits from the rule Michigan is defending.

The department also estimates the change would generate about 6,044 additional requests for evidence each year. Each of those is a delay, a legal bill and a period of uncertainty for the worker and the employer involved. Critics of the proposal say the real figure could be higher, because officers given a free hand to re-examine settled cases will inevitably find more to question. Supporters of the change argue that fresh review catches errors and fraud that deference lets through — but the department's own estimate concedes the immediate cost is thousands more RFEs a year.

What it means for extension applicants

Nothing changes today. Deference still applies, and the proposal is only a proposal until the department publishes a final rule. But workers with extensions coming up should plan for a world in which it disappears. Here is what that means in practice:

  • Keep your evidence file complete. If extensions are re-adjudicated from scratch, the documents that won the first approval — job description, qualifications, employer support letter — will need to be just as strong the second time.
  • File early. With more RFEs expected, the buffer between filing and the current status expiring matters more than ever. Talk to your employer or attorney about timing now, not when the deadline is close.
  • Watch the final rule. After comments close on 13 November, the department can publish a final rule, revise the proposal or withdraw it. Michigan's intervention is a push toward withdrawal, but it is not a guarantee.
  • Do not panic-file. A proposal is not a law. Filing an extension before you are ready, or switching status on rumour, can create problems that did not exist before.
The United States Capitol in Washington, D.C.

Photo: Noclip, Public domain — via Wikimedia Commons

How to comment before 13 November

The comment period closes on 13 November, and comments are accepted only through Regulations.gov. Anyone can submit a comment — workers, employers, universities, attorneys and members of the public. If you want your view counted, here is the process:

  • Go to Regulations.gov and search for docket USCIS-2026-0529, or for the proposal number 91 FR 65119.
  • Write in your own words how the change would affect you. Specific examples — a delayed extension, a job offer put at risk, a project disrupted — carry more weight than general statements.
  • Submit before the deadline. Comments filed after 13 November will not be part of the official record for this proposal.

This is the same route used for the other H-1B proposals moving through the system this autumn. Our November status check tracks the fee litigation, the pending appeals and the new I-129 form — all of which are moving on separate tracks from the deference rule.

What happens after the comment period

Once comments close, the department reviews the submissions and decides its next step. It has three options: publish a final rule largely as proposed, publish a revised final rule that softens the change, or withdraw the proposal altogether. There is no fixed timetable for that decision, and a final rule would normally set an effective date after publication rather than taking effect overnight.

The politics around the proposal are also moving. The 60-day grace period proposal saw its own comment period close on 10 November, and the broader H-1B debate is now part of the post-midterm immigration conversation in Congress. Michigan's opposition adds a heavyweight institutional voice to the record — and the department will have to answer it, in writing, if it proceeds.

For now, the practical advice is simple: deference still applies, the deadline to be heard is 13 November, and the next milestone is whatever the department does with the comments it receives. We will cover the final rule the moment it appears.

The US Citizenship and Immigration Services headquarters groundbreaking ceremony

Photo: U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS), Public domain — via Wikimedia Commons

Frequently asked questions

What is H-1B deference?
Deference is the rule that USCIS generally defers to its own prior approval of a petition when a new filing involves the same parties and the same facts. It means an extension is not re-decided from scratch. The current proposal would delete that rule at 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5).

Does the proposal change anything right now?
No. It is a proposal only. Deference still applies today, and nothing changes unless and until the Department of Homeland Security publishes a final rule after the comment period closes on 13 November.

How many petitions would the change affect?
The department estimates about 208,429 petitions a year were eligible for deference in fiscal years 2022 to 2025 — roughly 30% of all I-129 petitions — and about 6,044 additional requests for evidence a year if deference ends.

Official links / Sources

  • Department of Homeland Security proposal, 91 FR 65119, 14 October 2026, docket USCIS-2026-0529 — federalregister.gov / Regulations.gov
  • IANS reporting on the University of Michigan's comments opposing the proposal, 12 November 2026
  • US Citizenship and Immigration Services, Form I-129 and 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5)

Note: Immigration rules change frequently. Verify the current status of the deference proposal on Regulations.gov and the USCIS website before making decisions about your case. Nothing in this article is legal advice.

Read next

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Italy Work Visa 2027: Pre-Fill Opens Tomorrow, October 23 at 09:00 - Employer Checklist

Work Visas in Europe 2026: 5 Countries Actively Hiring Foreign Workers (Official Guide)

Canada Work Permit 2026: Who Can Apply and How the Process Works