US H-1B Extensions: 10 Days Left to Comment on Ending Deference to Past Approvals

Photo: Noclip, Public domain — via Wikimedia Commons
If you are on an H-1B, L-1 or another employment visa in the United States and you have ever renewed it smoothly because your last approval counted for something, a proposed rule could change that — and the window to have your say closes in 10 days, on 13 November 2026.
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) proposal is called "Removing Deference to Prior USCIS Determinations of Eligibility". It was published in the Federal Register on 14 October 2026 (DHS Docket No. USCIS-2026-0529), and comments are accepted only through regulations.gov. This article is not a repeat of our first explainer of the proposal — it is the action version: who the new USCIS numbers show would be hit hardest, what exactly would change, and how to comment before the deadline.
What "deference" means — and what would go
Since 2004, with interruptions, US immigration officers have generally deferred to a prior approval involving the same parties and the same facts when deciding an extension or a new petition — unless there was a material error, a material change, or new adverse information. That rule is written into regulation at 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5). The proposal would remove that regulation entirely.
In practice, deference is why a straightforward H-1B extension for the same worker, same employer and same role has often been approved without re-arguing the whole case from scratch. Without it, officers would decide each petition fresh, even where nothing has changed. The proposal covers all Form I-129 petitions — H-1B, L-1, O-1, TN, E and P workers — not only H-1B. The current rule stays in force until a final rule takes effect, so nothing changes for petitions being decided today. But the direction is clear, and the comment window is the moment to influence it.
The numbers: who would feel it most
USCIS data reported this week makes the impact concrete:
- About 399,000 H-1B petitions approved in fiscal 2024, of which 71% were for beneficiaries born in India
- About 258,000 approvals for continuing employment — the category that includes extensions — of which about 203,000, or 79%, went to Indian-born workers
- About 208,000 petitions a year would be affected, by DHS's own estimate
- H-1B petitions make up more than 75% of all Form I-129 filings
- Requests for evidence could rise by about 3 percentage points — roughly 6,000 additional requests a year
That is why reporting on the proposal has focused on Indian professionals: they account for nearly four in five continuing-employment approvals, so a rule that makes every extension a fresh decision falls most heavily on them. It is not a rule aimed at one nationality in its text — it covers every I-129 category — but the arithmetic of who renews most is what it is.
The policy itself has swung before: introduced in 2004, rescinded in 2017, reinstated in 2021 and written into regulation in 2024. This proposal would be the next swing. That history is worth knowing, because it means the rule is genuinely contested, not settled — which is exactly why the comment process exists.

Photo: Tony Webster, CC BY 2.0 — via Wikimedia Commons
How to comment before 13 November
- Go to regulations.gov and find DHS Docket No. USCIS-2026-0529, "Removing Deference to Prior USCIS Determinations of Eligibility".
- Submit your comment there, before the window closes on 13 November 2026. Email and mailed comments are not the channel for this docket — use regulations.gov.
- Be specific: say which visa category you are in, whether your petitions involve the same employer and role, and what a fresh review of an unchanged case would mean for you in practice (evidence, delays, costs).
- Do not copy a template word-for-word if you can avoid it — a personal, factual comment carries more weight than a duplicated one.
- Keep a copy or screenshot of your submission confirmation.
Two cautions. First, commenting does not change your current petition — the existing rule applies until a final rule takes effect, and a final rule would still need to go through the process. Second, no one can promise you the outcome of the proposal. What commenting does is put your experience on the record while the record is still open.
What to do about your own extension in the meantime
- If you have an extension coming up, prepare it as if deference may not help you: keep your evidence file complete, your employer letter current, and your role description consistent with your last approval.
- If anything has changed — employer, role, worksite, wages — assume it will be examined closely, because that is already the case under the current rule's exceptions.
- Talk to your employer's immigration counsel about timing: filing strategy around a possible rule change is fact-specific, and this article is not legal advice.
- Watch for the final rule, not just the proposal. The proposal, the comments and the final rule are three different stages, and only the final rule changes what officers must do.
For the wider H-1B picture this year — weighted lottery proposals, wage proposals and the fee debate — our H-1B rules map pulls the separate proposals together so you can see which ones are live, which are proposals, and which are only bills.

Photo: Kurt Kaiser, CC0 — via Wikimedia Commons
Frequently asked questions
Has deference already ended?
No. The current regulation, 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5), remains in force until a final rule takes effect. This is a proposal with a comment window closing 13 November 2026, not a change already in force.
Does the proposal only affect H-1B workers?
No. It covers all Form I-129 petitions, including H-1B, L-1, O-1, TN, E and P workers. H-1B dominates the numbers because it dominates I-129 filings, but the rule change would be broader.
I am not Indian. Does this affect me?
Yes, if you hold any I-129 status and you renew or extend. The data shows Indian-born workers are the largest share of continuing-employment approvals, but the rule would apply to every petitioner in those categories.
Official links / Sources
- US Department of Homeland Security, "Removing Deference to Prior USCIS Determinations of Eligibility", Federal Register, 14 October 2026, DHS Docket No. USCIS-2026-0529 (comments via regulations.gov, closing 13 November 2026)
- USCIS Annual Report to Congress (fiscal 2024 H-1B approval data) and USCIS data on continuing-employment approvals, as reported by IANS, Telangana Today, Sambad English and The Hans India (2 November 2026)
- DHS estimates in the proposal notice: ~208,000 petitions a year affected; requests for evidence up ~3 percentage points (~6,000 a year); H-1B over 75% of I-129 filings
Please note: immigration rules change, and the details above reflect a proposal, not a final rule, as reported at the time of writing. Always verify your own situation on the official USCIS and Federal Register pages, and get qualified legal advice for your own case, before acting. Nothing here guarantees any petition outcome.
Comments
Post a Comment