US SMARTER Act: The Bill to Replace the H-1B Lottery With a Points System - 85,000 Cap, a New Board and No DV Lottery

A second Republican vision for the H-1B program is now on the table - and it is very different from simply abolishing the visa. Congressman David Schweikert of Arizona, chairman of the Joint Economic Committee, outlined the SMARTER Act on 19 October 2026: a bill that would replace the current H-1B selection system with a merit-based framework favouring highly skilled, better-paid workers, create a points system for employment-based green cards, sharply restrict family-sponsored immigration and eliminate the Diversity Visa lottery. The bill, H.R. 10460, was introduced in the House on 16 September and sits in the Judiciary Committee. It is a proposal, not law - but it shows exactly where the reform debate is heading, so every H-1B worker and employer should understand it.

Photo: Tony Webster, CC BY-SA 2.0 - via Wikimedia Commons

What would replace the lottery

Under the proposal, H-1B selection would no longer be a random draw among registrations. Instead, preference would go to applicants based on their economic contribution, qualifications and labour-market demand. A new five-member body - the Skilled Migration and Recruitment of Talent Board - would determine annual immigration limits and allocate employment visas among industries, weighing labour shortages, unemployment, wages, productivity and economic growth.

The starting number matters: the initial limit for the proposed replacement system would be 85,000 - the same headline figure as today's H-1B cap - with later adjustments based on economic conditions set by the board. In other words, the bill does not begin by cutting the number; it changes who gets selected and who decides, moving that decision from a lottery to an appointed board applying economic tests.

The points system for green cards

The bill also proposes a points-based system for employment-based permanent immigration. Applicants would be assessed on age, education, English proficiency, salary and exceptional achievements. Reporting on the bill says applicants aged 26 to 30 would receive the highest age-related points, higher qualifications would improve scores, and salary would carry substantial weight - with extra credit for offers significantly above the median household income in the applicant's state.

Readers who follow other countries will recognise the model: it resembles the points logic Canada is expanding with its high-wage Express Entry points from 3 November. The direction of travel on both sides of the border is the same - away from chance and employer volume, toward measured economic contribution.

Photo: Tony Webster, CC BY 2.0 - via Wikimedia Commons

The two hard edges: family sponsorship and the DV lottery

The SMARTER Act goes well beyond skilled-worker selection. It would sharply restrict family-sponsored immigration - the route through which many current residents eventually bring parents and siblings - and it would eliminate the Diversity Visa (DV) lottery entirely, ending the green-card lottery that allocates visas to nationals of countries with low recent immigration to the US. Neither change is law, and both would face intense debate; but anyone whose long-term plan depends on a family petition or a DV entry should treat this bill as an early warning, not background noise.

How this differs from the other H-1B proposals

Three separate tracks are now running at once, and confusing them produces bad decisions. First, litigation: the $100,000 H-1B fee was vacated by a federal judge on 30 September and the administration appealed on 9 October - that fight is about a fee, in court. Second, abolition politics: the EXILE Act and statements calling to end H-1B outright, covered in our report on lawmakers calling to abolish H-1B. Third, this bill: replacement, not abolition - a points system with the same starting cap. The CRS has separately mapped the administration's own regulatory route - a weighted lottery favouring higher wages - in the analysis we summarised in the CRS map of H-1B rules. Of the four, only the court case and the regulations can change your position this year; bills must pass both chambers and be signed.

Photo: Michael Rivera, CC BY-SA 4.0 - via Wikimedia Commons

What workers and employers should do now

  • Nothing changes today. H.R. 10460 has been referred to committee; it has not passed the House, the Senate or been signed. Current H-1B rules, cap registration and extensions continue under existing law.
  • Build the profile every proposal rewards. Higher salary, scarce skills, strong English and documented achievements score well under the SMARTER points design, the weighted-lottery regulation and Canada's system alike.
  • Do not pay for "points assessments" for a bill. No agency can register you for a system that does not exist. Anyone selling that is selling fiction.
  • Watch the committee, not the headlines. The next real milestone is Judiciary Committee action on H.R. 10460; until then, treat coverage as debate-shaping, not decision-grade.

Official links and sources

  • US Congress - H.R. 10460, the SMARTER Act (Congress.gov): introduced 16 September 2026, referred to the House Judiciary Committee.
  • Reporting cross-checked against IANS coverage of Congressman Schweikert's 19 October announcement (via AP7AM and The Hawk, 20 October 2026).

Immigration rules change without notice, and proposed bills change as they move. Always confirm the current law on official US government pages before making decisions or payments.

FAQ

Is the H-1B lottery already replaced?

No. The SMARTER Act is a bill in committee. The existing H-1B cap and selection rules remain in force unless and until Congress passes a replacement and it is signed into law.

Would the cap fall below 85,000?

The bill sets the initial limit at 85,000; the proposed board could adjust later limits based on economic conditions. No lower figure is set in the proposal as reported.

What happens to the Diversity Visa lottery under this bill?

It would be eliminated. That is a proposal only - the DV program continues under current law unless Congress changes it.

Read next

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Italy Work Visa 2027: Pre-Fill Opens Tomorrow, October 23 at 09:00 - Employer Checklist

Work Visas in Europe 2026: 5 Countries Actively Hiring Foreign Workers (Official Guide)

Canada Work Permit 2026: Who Can Apply and How the Process Works